Automotive Electronics Content electric cars News University of Bath Viewpoints

Comment: The future is electric

Comment: The future is electric motors

Comment: The future is electric motors

Once we consider electric automobiles, it is fairly often from the attitude of zero emissions or environmentally pleasant know-how, we additionally typically are likely to assume when it comes to restricted vary and efficiency. Nevertheless, this is turning into much less true with every passing yr.

The quickest automotive on the planet from Zero-60 mph is not an unique supercar however a 100% electric racing automotive constructed by college college students, such because the AMZ (Educational Motorsports Membership Zurich – comprising college students from ETH Zurich and the Lucerne College of Utilized Sciences and Arts, pictured above), which achieved a startling time of 1.513 seconds to realize 60 mph. To place this in perspective the well-known Bugatti Veyron can handle the identical in round 2.5 seconds. Tesla has modified the notion of the electric automotive with its high-performance automobiles which might be additionally capable of obtain efficient ranges of greater than 300 miles.

As we will see with the efficiency figures above and contemplating how using KERS in F1 has offered drivers with a lift button, electric motors are extremely mild, environment friendly and highly effective.

Within the brief and medium time period there is a transparent stepping stone by way of using hybrid propulsion methods that may reap the benefits of clear and emission free city motoring and longer vary inner combustion engine (ICE) extra-urban journeys. This is an efficient and smart strategy on this interval of transition from ICE to future propulsion techniques which are primarily electric.

Hybrid automobiles appear to supply a low emission strategy, nevertheless what are the problems with shifting to extremely and even zero emission automobiles within the future and why are they a lot costlier? If we break down the know-how inside an electric automotive we will shortly see the place a few of the points come up, and the place the issues may lie.

Actual world

The place does this depart us now in the actual world of most of the people? Clearly the know-how to realize excessive efficiency is right here and now, and it appears that evidently battery know-how is enhancing quickly to offer extra vary than was beforehand potential, nevertheless there is nonetheless hesitation to undertake these new electric automobiles within the numbers that may make an actual impression on the extent of carbon emissions; what is the stumbling block?

Generally it is fairly easy, value. Proudly owning a Tesla sounds nice, however is too costly for many of us. It is value remembering that the electric automotive predates the interior combustion powered automotive, so we might legitimately ask the query why it has taken so lengthy to supply a car that is sensible financially in addition to from a efficiency perspective?


Trendy motors (resembling “BrushLess DC Motors – BLDC”) can present a superb energy to weight ratio and don’t require any upkeep. This contrasts with older brushed motors, reminiscent of the type you may see on an electric practice set the place carbon brushes wanted to get replaced periodically. EVs don’t require a gearbox and combine seamlessly into a contemporary automotive’s electrical system. They’re additionally quite simple to supply.

There is one element that is a possible drawback: the shortage of so referred to as “rare earth” supplies, particularly Neodymium which is utilized in everlasting magnets and BLDC motors. If the world modifications over from inner combustion to electric motors, it will require tons of of tens of millions of those BLDC motors to be manufactured. Neodymium is not intrinsically uncommon; nevertheless it is troublesome and costly to mine and isolate, subsequently there is a danger that because the evolution of electric automobiles gathers tempo, then this might turn into a problem.

Various choices such because the Switched Reluctance Motor (SRM) don’t require these supplies, nevertheless are extra ideally suited to excessive velocity motors quite than the comparatively sluggish speeds of automotive propulsion. However, it is truthful to say that the electric motor itself is properly understood, financial and environment friendly as a major mover for automobiles.


The different important distinction between a standard ICE car and most electric automobiles is the gasoline storage system. In a combustion system (resembling Petrol or Diesel engines) a big benefit is that the gasoline must be combined in comparatively low densities with air, which might be obtained instantly from the environment. This air/gasoline or stoichiometric ratio is about 14.5:1 for Petrol and 14.7:1 for Diesel engines.

In distinction in an electric car all the gasoline (the electrical energy) must be saved in a battery. The ensuing power density for many electric automobiles is subsequently a lot decrease. An exception to this is the Hydrogen gasoline cell energy automotive, which makes use of liquid Hydrogen because the gasoline supply, which might be mixed with Oxygen from the environment and crammed in a really comparable method to present ICE based mostly automobiles. One disadvantage with this strategy is that the majority nations lack any appropriate hydrogen infrastructure. Whereas this is a debatable level (should you construct it, will they arrive?) the price of producing Hydrogen is additionally excessive, and requires vital power to extract and retailer.

The actuality of each carbon prices and decrease effectivity in comparison with battery energy electric automobiles mitigates towards hydrogen for the mass market shopper automobiles of the future.

The concern for all electric automobiles now is the numerous further value of a giant sufficient battery pack to offer a sensible vary for the driving force. Proper now, the premium worth of electric automobiles may be traced again to the extra value required for the battery pack.


What about security? Lithium-Ion batteries have a historical past of very excessive power density in comparison with different battery applied sciences, nevertheless there have been unlucky incidents with batteries catching hearth. This has occurred in shopper merchandise and in some electric automobiles (EV). Does this make EVs extra harmful than ICE based mostly automobiles? I don’t consider so.

Automotive producers are constructing battery packs with rigorously monitored thermal measurements inside and controlling the cost and discharge charges to take care of them inside protected limits. Actually, there have been only a few incidents involving EVs. To place this in perspective the Nationwide Hearth Safety Affiliation within the USA reported 174,000 automotive fires in 2015, and knowledge from the UK house workplace in 2018 reported simply over 11,000 car fires in 2017.

Though absolutely the variety of EVs on the roads are nonetheless small (nonetheless lower than 2% of latest car registrations within the UK for instance) there is no proof that EVs usually tend to catch hearth, CNN reported in 2018 that for a similar mileage, the prospect of a automotive hearth was considerably larger for a petroleum automotive than for an EV.

It is in all probability nonetheless too early to make any categorical statements concerning the relative security of EV batteries, nevertheless when an EV catches hearth it makes the information, because of the novelty of the know-how. Petrol is harmful and extremely flammable, much more so in vapour type, as is Diesel, nevertheless we’ve turn into used to the precautions that we absorb filling stations for instance.

Battery know-how is persevering with to evolve and new supplies with strong state know-how supply a future of very protected battery know-how with virtually no danger of fireside. As with all new know-how, the tempo of analysis and improvement in battery know-how is extremely speedy, and the prospects for radically improved battery know-how are excellent certainly. Charging infrastructure is increasing quickly, and it is turning into regular to see electric car charging factors on main routes and throughout our cities and cities, making it a lot simpler to maintain shifting wherever we’re.

Quick charging

Charging and power conversion are different areas which have seen main enhancements in a brief interval, with speedy charging turning into attainable with trendy energy electronics units (comparable to Silicon Carbide) capable of tolerate a lot larger currents and brief time period temperatures to offer the facility converters to cost the battery packs in EVs and drive the motor ever motor effectively. Superior management methodologies are additionally offering greater effectivity of operation for each motor drives and chargers. Quick charging is not restricted by the facility electronics however quite the thermal limits of present battery know-how. The greater the present, the upper the temperature ensuing within the battery, which for present Lithium-Ion know-how can’t be exceeded with out the danger of injury to the person cells within the battery pack.

The future for electric automobiles

In lots of respects, the future of electric automobiles seems very robust, and the obstacles to wider adoption are receding quickly. The great thing about the electric automobiles of the future is their relative simplicity, with a lot easier and extra compact propulsion methods than typical ICE. The key limitation from a technical and business perspective of electric automobiles stays the price of the battery pack, nevertheless as this know-how continues to enhance, as with different new applied sciences the fee will scale back. Whereas this value discount has been dramatic within the final decade, it is predicted that with the expansion of the Chinese language automotive business, this might be tempered by a serious improve in demand for batteries and consequently there could possibly be a world provide scarcity. The UK Authorities Enterprise, Power and Industrial Technique Committee Electric automobiles: driving the transition report in 2018 highlights this level and predicts a unbroken discount in LiOn cell worth, however at a a lot decreased price.

Projecting out to a decade from now it is affordable to foretell that the power density and price could have progressed to some extent the place the vary of a typical electric car shall be according to that of an ICE based mostly car, and the return on funding time will probably be brief sufficient to justify the funding in a premium for buying an electric car. Trying to the future one facet of the automotive business that may require a serious adjustment is the upkeep and guarantee help for patrons, automotive corporations and retailers.

Coaching shall be an important a part of this for mechanics and sellers to make sure that automobiles are maintained safely and appropriately, and guarantee repairs on battery packs would require specialist expertise and instruments. Lastly, with an ever-widening charging community, and lowered charging occasions, utilizing electric automobiles for a wider vary of journeys (past the prevailing candy spot of shorter, often city journeys) is turning into a sensible choice for increasingly more motorists throughout the nation. The number of automobiles from compact supermini electric automobiles to excessive efficiency sports activities automobiles supplies the motorist with a large option to go well with virtually each requirement.

Possession in EVs

The world is clearly shifting in the direction of a future of electric automobiles, with growing numbers of automobiles on the street as proof of that transition. Will probably be an extended course of with the preliminary excessive value of EVs and limitations of vary typically, plus the legacy of ICE based mostly automobiles remaining out there for a few years after manufacturing, nevertheless the development of speedy improve in possession in EVs is pointing in the direction of this development persevering with.

Professor Peter Wilson, College of Tub

window.___gcfg = lang: ‘en-US’;
(perform(w, d, s)
perform go()
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], load = perform(url, id)
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.src = url; = id;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
load(‘//join.fb.internet/en/all.js#xfbml=1’, ‘fbjssdk’);
load(‘’, ‘gplus1js’);
load(‘//’, ‘tweetjs’);

if (w.addEventListener) w.addEventListener(“load”, go, false);
else if (w.attachEvent) w.attachEvent(“onload”,go);
(window, doc, ‘script’));