Astrophotography Gear Content Gear Reviews mobile nightscapes smartphone urban nightscapes

ZenFone 4 Pro vs. U11 vs. V30 vs. S8 – Lonely Speck

ZenFone 4 Pro vs. U11 vs. V30 vs. S8 – Lonely Speck

Let’s check out 4 of the perfect smartphones in a low-light capturing battle. We examine city nightscape photographs from the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro, HTC U11, LG V30 and Samsung Galaxy S8.

All 4 of those telephones have been launched in 2017 as flagship fashions from their respective producers. All of them sport high-end specs, guide publicity controls, SDXC card slots and RAW file recording, all fascinating options for images fanatics

Additionally essential for journey photographers: they’re all obtainable as unlocked world GSM telephones. You should purchase them unlocked and and not using a contract at B&H photograph and use them on any service with a GSM community.

This images comparability is as a lot a check of every smartphone’s hardware as it’s a comparability of every producer’s design philosophy regarding the units’ cameras. Let’s see how properly ASUS, HTC, LG and Samsung construct a cellular images expertise and the way nicely every of those telephones performs at night time images.

Let’s assessment the specs and consumer expertise design of every telephone, in alphabetical order, by producer.

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Digital camera Specs

  • Twin-Digital camera (Normal Extensive and Medium Telephoto)
  • MicroSDXC Card Slot
  • Main Digital camera: 12MP Sony IMX362 half.55″, 1.4µm pixels, three.95mm f/1.7 lens (25mm equiv. FOV)
  • Secondary Digital camera: 16MP Sony IMX351 1/three.06″, 1.0µm pixels, 5.54mm f/2.6 lens (50mm equiv. FOV)

The ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro is one in every of two telephones on this comparability that has twin cameras. It has a quick f/1.7 broad angle main digital camera with a 25mm equal focal size and a secondary digital camera with a 50mm equal focal size.

The secondary digital camera makes use of a barely smaller sensor and a slower f/2.6 lens but in addition has a barely greater decision 16MP sensor. This secondary digital camera permits the ZenFone 4 Pro to make use of parallax depth mapping to simulate brief depth of area portraits.

For this comparability, the decrease decision 12MP main digital camera will definitely perform as the higher low-light digital camera: it has the bigger sensor, bigger pixels and quicker (decrease f/quantity) lens. That stated, we’ll nonetheless put each cameras to the check in low-light circumstances.

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Digital camera Consumer Expertise

The ZenFone 4 Pro defaults to Auto mode each time the digital camera app is first opened from the house display. The guide publicity controls could be enabled by opening Pro mode, both by swiping from the left or by choosing the “Pro” button close to the shutter button (assuming Pro mode is about because the pinned mode of selection). As a way to maintain the digital camera in Pro mode between makes use of, the consumer should re-open the app by way of the just lately used apps switcher. If the app is opened by way of its residence display or app drawer icon, it is going to reset to Auto mode.

ASUS isn’t an organization I often consider when looking for smartphones,. That stated, the ZenFone 4 Pro has among the best digital camera consumer interfaces of any smartphone digital camera I’ve tried, notably for guide publicity controls. Pro mode give the consumer entry to all the following features:

  • White Stability: Auto, Tungsten, Fluorescent, Daylight, Cloudy, Kelvin (2700Okay-7500Okay)
  • Publicity Compensation: +/- 2EV
  • ISO: Auto, 25-3200
  • Vast/Tele Digital camera Choice:  Auto, Large (25mm), Tele (50mm)
  • Shutter Time: Auto, 1/10000 – 32s
  • Autofocus and Guide Focus
  • Auto Reset Publicity

And on the left aspect toolbar:

  • Flash
  • Self Timer
  • Facet Ratio
  • HDR
  • Settings
ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Camera Interface

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Digital camera Interface

A lot of the main features of the ZenFone 4 Pro digital camera may be modified by way of the fitting hand toolbar (in panorama orientation). When pressed, every perform opens a small adjustment dial that may be scrolled to vary the parameter. The Broad/Tele digital camera selector permits for 3 totally different features: Auto, Tele and Extensive the place Auto will mechanically change from the vast to the tele digital camera when 2x zoom is reached by way of the pinch-to-zoom gesture.

Flash and different secondary controls just like the self-timer are managed with buttons on the left hand toolbar. Some notable features like metering (center-weighted/common) and determination choice are hidden behind the settings button on this left hand toolbar.

The consumer expertise could be very a lot geared in the direction of images lovers. It really works identical to a DSLR when it comes to obtainable perform and the dial type UI parts make altering parameters like shutter velocity or ISO very quick an intuitive. Within the ZenFone’s Pro mode, all main features like shutter velocity, ISO, focus mode and white stability can be set to “Auto”, successfully permitting customers to imitate the performance of the standard M/A/S/P modes on a DSLR. You’ll be able to management the points of publicity you need and depart every part else on auto.

ASUS has additionally included an “Auto Reset Exposure” button on the best hand toolbar that may shortly reset all parameters to auto ought to that you must shortly snap a impartial publicity in Pro mode. I additionally love the inclusion of additional ISO vary: the digital camera can go to an extremely low ISO 25 and a excessive of 3200.

The ZenFone 4 Pro additionally supplies a large amount of suggestions: There’s an optionally available “gradienter” or digital degree that exhibits orientation for each roll and pitch. Moreover, an lively publicity meter continually exhibits the anticipated publicity worth, even when utilizing guide modes, making it a lot simpler to guage publicity brightness in tough conditions. That is additionally accompanied by a luminosity histogram that’s very useful for gauging publicity. The interface even exhibits the f/quantity worth for the digital camera that’s getting used (f/1.7 for large and f/2.6 for tele) although it’s a parameter that may’t be adjusted because of the cameras’ fastened apertures. It’s a small element however it’s useful when understanding publicity changes when switching between extensive and telephoto cameras.

One notable function that I found when utilizing the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro is the best way through which the guide focus perform works. The guide focus adjustment dial permits the consumer to focus to the complete vary of focal distances out there to the lens from close-up macro to infinity and even just a little previous infinity. Most cameras are designed to have the ability to focus previous infinity so as to help the search performance of the autofocus techniques. It’s a necessity of most part detection autofocus methods. However on the ZenFone 4 Pro, if the consumer dials the guide focus wheel all the best way to the marked infinity setting on the finish of the wheel’s journey, the main target returns precisely to a calibrated infinity place for good important focus at infinity. That signifies that the ASUS engineers truly calibrated and marked the lens on every digital camera for correct infinity focus place. That’s one thing that I’ve by no means seen on a smartphone digital camera. Most different smartphones’ infinity marks are wildly off in my expertise. Bravo ASUS.

Whereas in Pro mode, entry to film recording is on the market always with the report button slightly below the shutter. Films are recorded with all of the guide publicity settings utilized which means that it’s potential to create absolutely guide publicity movies, a uncommon function for a smartphone digital camera. Shutter presses are almost on the spot, even with RAW recording enabled, a powerful show of the digital camera’s velocity. It must be famous, nevertheless, that it’s not attainable to shoot in steady shutter mode when RAW recording is enabled. Switching to JPEG recording permits the photographer to carry the shutter button and quickly hearth off a sequence of photographs.

General, the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro’s digital camera consumer expertise has just about the whole lot I would like in an fanatic digital camera. It’s intuitive and quick has a superb function set for critical photographers.

HTC U11 Digital camera Specs

  • Single Digital camera (Normal Broad)
  • MicroSDXC Card Slot
  • Main Digital camera: 12MP Sony IMX362 half.55″, 1.4µm pixels, 4.28mm f/1.7 lens (26.2mm equiv. FOV)

The HTC U11 sports activities the identical Sony IMX362 sensor because the ASUS ZenFone 4 however has a really barely longer focal size lens (26.2mm vs 24mm equiv. FOV) with an identical f/1.7 aperture. The U11 isn’t a twin digital camera telephone however its main digital camera specs are just like the opposite cameras on this comparability and the digital camera has been extensively considered probably the greatest cellular cameras based on DXO. It options guide controls and RAW seize in order that makes it a great candidate for night time images.

HTC U11 Digital camera Consumer Expertise

The U11 consumer expertise is considerably of a combined bag when in comparison with, say, the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. It has the naked commonplace publicity options that we might anticipate nevertheless it has one thing to be desired when it comes to group and ease-of-use. It’s additionally randomly lacking some shutter velocity choice functionality. Extra on that later.

Just like the ZenFone 4 Pro, the U11 additionally encompasses a separate “Pro” mode to entry guide publicity controls. In Pro mode, U11 customers can achieve entry to the next parameters:

  • Customized Program Save Slots (C1, C2, C3)
  • Auto Program Modes: Full Auto, Night time, Sport, Macro
  • White Stability: (2300Okay-7500Okay)
  • Publicity Compensation: Auto,+/- 3EV
  • ISO: Auto, 100-800
  • Shutter Time: Auto, 1/8000 – 32s
  • Autofocus and Guide Focus

And on the left aspect toolbar:

  • Flash
  • File Format: RAW/Jpeg
  • Self-Timer
  • Facet Ratio
  • Settings
HTC U11 Camera Interface

HTC U11 Digital camera Interface

The HTC U11 has probably the most Spartan wanting interface and but I’ve probably the most to say about it, which I’m unsure is an effective factor. In contrast to the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro, the first features are adjusted by way of buttons on the underside of the display (in panorama orientation). When pressed, every perform opens a slider above that button. Every parameter (white stability, publicity, ISO, shutter and focus) can have their respective adjustment sliders open suddenly. It’s good to have the ability to regulate every slider immediately, however they’re additionally drawn immediately over the reside view feed making the digital camera appear terribly cluttered when all parameter sliders are open. Moreover, re-opening the app after having set any guide controls, even upon closing them beforehand, causes the sliders to re-open and thus re-clutter the interface.

Flash management is immediately accessible from the left-hand toolbar and different secondary controls just like the self-timer, file format and facet ratio are hidden behind the left-toolbar. Some notable features like metering or HDR management are unavailable in Pro mode.

Whereas HTC has made a digital camera that features a lot of the primary guide performance we might anticipate, it feels partly missing and clunky. There’s no digital degree and customary white stability settings like “cloudy” or “daylight” will not be marked. Customized white stability is just selectable by way of the Kelvin temperature which is a bit counter-intuitive with out follow.

ISO is restricted to only ISO 100-800 and lacks the prolonged excessive and low vary obtainable on the ZenFone 4 Pro. The digital camera additionally lacks any type of publicity worth readout which makes estimation of absolutely guide exposures very troublesome when in comparison with what I discovered to anticipate of the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro.

Guide focus controls perform high-quality however permit the consumer to regulate previous infinity and there’s no devoted infinity setting like on the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro and there are not any focus aids like peaking. Sliding the main target slider to its far restrict places the lens distance previous infinity, leading to blurry pictures so care have to be taken when focusing.

One of many strangest issues concerning the HTC U11’s guide digital camera controls is that it’s lacking some lengthy publicity shutter settings. Above shutter occasions longer than 2 seconds, it’s not attainable to decide on third and even half cease increments. Moreover, the interface is lacking 4 seconds as potential shutter time choice. The slider jumps from 2 seconds, immediately as much as eight seconds, an entire two cease leap. That makes tuning lengthy exposures in that vary far more troublesome. It frankly looks like a mistake on a part of the HTC designers. If a 2 second photograph is somewhat too darkish, good luck bumping it up only a cease, you’ll be pressured to bump it as much as eight seconds if you’d like it to be brighter and that’s more likely to be a bit an excessive amount of. Give us 4 seconds HTC.

The publicity preview when capturing in low-light pictures doesn’t seem to mirror the brightness of the anticipated publicity. Normally, capturing in darkish circumstances turns into just a little harder because the preview tends to seem fairly darkish, particularly if utilizing an extended shutter with a low ISO.

Even at brief shutter occasions, the digital camera additionally appears to have numerous delay whereas exposing. When RAW exposures are enabled, there’s a few half second delay after urgent the shutter whereas the telephone says “Processing…” earlier than the digital camera is obtainable to make use of once more. Whereas the shutter response is quick upon urgent the button, the processing time makes the digital camera really feel comparatively sluggish.

However the U11 has a number of good options, too. Every publicity parameter might be set to “Auto” and it presents three customized perform modes. That makes it potential to save lots of your favourite guide settings for any given state of affairs as a customized mode that may be accessed later at any time. Need to pressure the digital camera to all the time use the bottom ISO potential whereas routinely selecting shutter velocity? Set the ISO to 100 and shutter to auto and reserve it as a customized perform. It’s additionally straightforward to reset all publicity parameters again to Auto by choosing the “Auto” program mode from the left-most management on the decrease toolbar.

Finally, the HTC U11’s digital camera interface appears rushed and unpolished. It’s a little bit of a disgrace as a result of we all know the hardware is succesful… it’s the identical sensor because the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. It simply appears that the software program designers at HTC didn’t actually take their guide digital camera software program all that critically. That stated, the performance is there. It’s usable and the ensuing pictures, even at night time, are typically spectacular… I simply want the interface to create stated pictures was slightly extra pleasant and enjoyable to make use of.

LG V30 Digital camera Specs

  • Twin-Digital camera (Commonplace Extensive and Extremely Vast)
  • MicroSDXC Card Slot
  • Main Digital camera: 16MP Sony IMX351 1/three.06″, 1.0µm pixels, 4.03mm f/1.6 lens (28mm equiv. FOV)
  • Secondary Digital camera: 13MP Samsung Sensor, 1.0µm, 1.78mm f/2.6 lens (12mm equiv. FOV)

The LG V30 has barely smaller sensors for its most important and secondary cameras in comparison with the HTC and ASUS above, however it additionally has the quickest aperture (f/1.6) on its main shooter to make up for the marginally smaller sensor.

Along with the marginally quicker f/1.6 aperture (not that the f/1.7 apertures of the earlier cameras was dangerous), a singular function of the V30 is the inclusion of an extremely vast angle f/1.9 lens. This secondary digital camera has a 120°  area of view, a particularly vast angle that’s wonderful for capturing large sweeping landscapes. Personally, I discover the broad angle lens to be extra sensible than the inclusion of a telephoto, notably when capturing landscapes and cityscapes.

LG V30 Digital camera Consumer Expertise

The just like the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro, the LG V30 defaults to Auto mode each time the digital camera app is first opened from the house display. The guide publicity controls could be opened by choosing the “Mode” button the left toobar, and choosing “Manual” mode. Sadly, if the digital camera is closed and re-opened, the digital camera resets to Auto mode.

When it comes to guide publicity controls, the LG V30 could be very full-featured. The interface is exclusive in that LG utilized the extra actual property of the V30’s 18:9 facet ratio display to provide the controls their very own distinctive area. In guide mode, customers have entry to the next controls from the underside toolbar:

  • White Stability: Auto, Tungsten, Fluorescent, Daylight, Cloudy, Kelvin (2300Okay-7400Okay)
  • Autofocus and Guide Focus
  • Publicity Compensation: +/- 2EV
  • ISO: Auto, 50-3200
  • Shutter Time: Auto, 1/4000 – 30s
  • Auto Reset Publicity

On the left aspect toolbar:

  • Flash
  • Selfie Digital camera
  • Colour Profiles
  • Mode Choice
  • Settings

And on the prime of the display:

  • Extensive/Extremely Vast Digital camera Choice:  (Broad (28mm), Extremely Large (12mm))
LG V30 Camera Interface

LG V30 Digital camera Interface

The LG V30 jogs my memory a bit little bit of the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro when it comes to management and consumer interface (based mostly on the right-hand dial/slider). It has a number of the similar actual conveniences like an digital degree (though it solely exhibits rolls and doesn’t present pitch), f/quantity readout, a real-time histogram readout and a quick “Auto Reset” button that immediately resets all parameters to automated.  When an publicity parameter is chosen for adjustment, the digital camera opens a devoted slider/dial on the best aspect toolbar that permits for quick intuitive adjustment. For every parameter, an “Auto” button is all the time obtainable above the slider to reset that publicity parameter again to automated mode.

Secondary controls like flash and shade profiles are accessible from the left hand toolbar. A couple of helpful options like monitoring focus and site tagging management are hidden behind the settings button on the left-hand toolbar. It must be famous that HDR controls are solely out there within the digital camera’s auto mode.

Distinctive to the LG V30 is their “Graphy” perform which is accessible by means of the right-hand toolbar. Graphy exhibits quite a lot of instance pictures that permit customers to pick to imitate the publicity parameters essential to mimic that sort of photograph. It’s principally a solution to help with studying guide controls with a view to obtain a sure look. I feel it’s a novel concept that’s just a little bit higher than a one-size matches all “Auto” mode. It’s kind of like having devoted “Sports” or “Night Portrait” or “Fireworks” modes.

It ought to be famous that the V30’s guide focus controls are similar to the ASUS ZenFone 4 and positively higher than the HTC U11. As soon as once more, it attainable to by chance focus previous infinity however the V30 provides one thing distinctive that we haven’t seen but in our comparability: Focus Peaking. With Focus Peaking enabled, the interface attracts shiny teal strains on sharp, in-focus edges. It’s efficient and really useful for attaining guide focus in most circumstances. That stated, the function is slightly restricted in low-light conditions. Finally, if sharp focus is tough to realize, it’s all the time potential to make use of the pinch-to-zoom perform, then modify focus after which zoom again out earlier than taking a photograph.

It ought to be famous that guide focus shouldn’t be obtainable but in addition not needed on the Extremely Vast Angle digital camera: it’s fastened at infinity which is ok given its extremely giant depth of area. All the things from a few foot in entrance of the lens to infinity will probably be in focus when utilizing the Extremely Vast Angle digital camera.

I like that LG has widespread white stability setting (tungsten, daylight, cloudy, and so on.) marked on its Kelvin white stability scale. I additionally like that the ISO vary is comparatively giant: it goes from ISO 50 as much as ISO 3200. When setting guide controls, the publicity compensation meter mechanically reads out the anticipated publicity worth, making it simpler to guage guide exposures in tough lighting.

General, LG’s strategy to their guide digital camera mode on the V30 exhibits that they care about making a really succesful and straightforward to make use of digital camera. It’s full featured and intuitive to make use of and provides some issues unavailable on the opposite digital camera fashions just like the extremely vast angle digital camera. It has a pair quirks although: it resets to Auto publicity mode if the app is closed and there isn’t a devoted “infinity” setting for the first digital camera’s guide focusing.

Samsung Galaxy S8 Digital camera Specs

  • Single Digital camera (Commonplace Broad)
  • MicroSDXC Card Slot
  • Main Digital camera: 12 MP Sony IMX333 or S5K2L2 ISOCELL half.55″, 1.4µm pixels, 4.2mm f/1.7 lens (26mm equiv. FOV)

The Samsung Galaxy S8’s single important digital camera includes a 12 MP sensor, both a Sony or ISOCELL mannequin, relying on the area of the telephone. Both sensor is meant to be principally equivalent. They each sound comparable in specification to the IMX362 that we’ve seen on the HTC U11 and ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. Sensor measurement, pixel measurement, and determination are all similar and so we should always anticipate comparable efficiency. The lens is a comparatively quick 26mm equal focal size with an f/1.7 aperture. There’s no secondary digital camera on the S8.

Samsung Galaxy S8 Digital camera Consumer Expertise

The Galaxy S8 feels totally different from all the opposite telephones on this evaluate, largely as a result of its smaller measurement bezels and curved display. We additionally reviewed the S8 fairly than the bigger S8+ model. The S8 and S8+ are similar in specification apart from bodily measurement. Swiping from the left within the default digital camera app permits the photographer to modify to different digital camera modes together with “Pro” publicity mode. The digital camera app remembers the earlier mode you have been in so it’s potential to make use of Pro publicity mode, depart the app and return on to Pro mode once more by re-opening the app by way of any means. The S8 instantly feels most just like the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro when it comes to its format. On the right-side toolbar (in panorama orientation), we will entry:

  • Publicity Compensation: +/- 2EV
  • White Stability: Auto, Tungsten, Fluorescent, Daylight, Cloudy, Kelvin (2300Okay-10000Okay)
  • Autofocus and Guide Focus
  • Colour Profiles
  • Shutter Time: Auto, 1/24000 – 10s
  • ISO: Auto, 50-800

And on the left-side toolbar:

  • Settings
  • AF Mode: Middle or Multi
  • Metering Mode: Matrix, Middle-weighted, Spot
  • Flash
  • Selfie Cam
Samsung Galaxy S8 Camera Interface

Samsung Galaxy S8 Digital camera Interface

Hidden behind the S8’s settings menu are a couple of extra helpful and notable controls similar to monitoring AF, automated distortion correction, self-timer and determination choice. The S8 is the one telephone on this comparability that provides fast entry to publicity metering controls (Spot, center-weighted, and so forth.) immediately from the primary digital camera interface and it additionally boasts the quickest potential shutter time at 1/24000 of a second. That stated, the telephone additionally has a shorter potential lengthy publicity time restrict at a max of 10 seconds.

One function missing on the S8’s guide digital camera controls is a method to shortly reset all publicity parameters again to “Auto”. Every parameter have to be chosen after which reset to Auto individually. It looks like a small omission however it may possibly sluggish the workflow of the digital camera in some conditions.

The Galaxy S8’s publicity controls are in any other case similar to the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro and LG V30: choose a parameter to vary and it’ll open a slider/dial on the suitable sidebar that may be swiped to vary that parameter. It’s easy and acquainted and retains the controls out of the best way.

The S8 lacks an digital degree and in addition lacks the power to assign the ISO management to Auto when the shutter time is about manually. Meaning it’s not potential to shoot as if utilizing a “shutter priority with auto ISO” mode. The inverse, nevertheless, works: you’ll be able to set ISO manually and have the digital camera mechanically management the shutter time.

The publicity compensation management additionally acts as a meter readout, displaying your anticipated impartial publicity in EV stops (+/-2EV) which makes it simpler to guage absolutely guide publicity settings.

The general operation of the Galaxy S8 is good and quick. Focus could be very quick to accumulate and the shutter has almost zero delay, even when RAW seize is enabled. I do want that my copy of the S8 was slightly higher a hitting infinity focus in guide focus mode (I discovered some variation in success when making an attempt to set guide focus to infinity) and I additionally want the digital camera software program allowed for exposures longer than 10 seconds. Aside from that, the interface design of the S8’s guide digital camera controls is fairly good.

Consumer Expertise Winner: ZenFone 4 Pro

The ZenFone 4 Pro digital camera consumer expertise was very clearly designed by photographers for photographers that need probably the most out of their smartphone expertise. Every thing concerning the ZenFone 4 Pro will acquainted to an skilled photographer. It presents many options we might solely anticipate from a full-fledged DSLR, however in a consumer interface that’s quicker and extra pleasant to make use of. Small particulars like a calibrated infinity setting for guide focus and an digital degree with each pitch and roll suggestions are a pair the issues that make the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro stand out.

Stay view brightness and Publicity simulation

Focusing and composing in darkish circumstances is definitely a problem for a lot of cameras. Once we examine the 4 cameras on this assessment, we observed some distinct variations in conduct when capturing in particularly darkish circumstances.

To match every telephone’s reside view brightness, we dialed in a guide publicity of (roughly) 10 seconds at ISO 100. Within the night time cityscape circumstances we have been capturing, the publicity settings chosen must be overexposed by a minimum of 2 stops. Consequently, we should always anticipate every digital camera to point out an excessively vibrant preview picture and an publicity meter pegged at +2 EV. What we truly acquired diversified significantly from telephone to telephone.

Stay View and Publicity Simulation Comparability. Full Decision.

The ZenFone 4 Pro has probably the most correct illustration of brightness from what we should always anticipate a picture to appear to be if overexposed as we anticipate. The reside view picture seems to be shiny as anticipated and the publicity meter reads “+2EV”, indicating that the digital camera expects the present settings to overexpose. The extra I exploit the ZenFone 4 Pro, the extra I feel that the ASUS designers took the design of the digital camera within the ZenFone 4 Pro very critically.

The HTC U11 is overly darkish and lacks an publicity meter studying solely. For that cause, the HTC U11 could be very troublesome to make use of in darkish circumstances… it merely doesn’t correctly simulate publicity settings within the stay view feed. It ought to be famous that when utilizing the U11, growing the ISO did increase the reside view feed to be barely brighter, which is useful for composition, however we anticipated it to be brighter anyway in an effort to simulate our brilliant 10 second publicity setting. It might be a ache to wish to extend the ISO simply to compose and focus earlier than needing to scale back it once more with a view to shoot the ultimate publicity.

The V30 seems to be comparatively near the ZenFone 4 Pro however the reside view picture is a bit too darkish and the publicity meter is mistakenly studying -Zero.3EV. It seems just like the V30 meter readings are based mostly off the life view picture and that makes them not probably the most correct in low-light. In reasonably brighter circumstances, I’ve discovered the V30’s reside view to correctly simulate publicity and the meter to be fairly correct. Seems to be like we’re simply hitting the restrict of the V30’s stay view with this darkish scene.

Lastly, the Galaxy S8 has a comparatively darkish reside view picture however it’s nonetheless fairly enough for composition. It’s definitely not a great visible illustration of what we should always anticipate however it might nonetheless be potential to border a shot. That famous, the publicity meter correctly reads “+2EV” as anticipated. If the ISO is modified to a better worth, the stay view picture additionally will increase in brightness, just like the HTC U11. That’s a sign that the S8 shouldn’t be correctly trying to simulate publicity for the stay view picture. No less than the meter readings are correct.

Stay View Brightness and Publicity Simulation Winner: ZenFone 4 Pro

General, I feel the ZenFone 4 Pro does one of the best job at displaying a usefully shiny stay view picture when composing at night time. It’s stay view feed is far more on par with what we should always anticipate from knowledgeable digital camera and that makes night time composition and visually judging publicity simpler. It’s meter appears fairly correct in robust, darkish circumstances too.

Low Mild Picture High quality: ISO Invariance and Shadow Noise

A good way to characterize the low mild efficiency of a digital camera is to carry out an ISO-invariance check. To carry out the check, we shoot RAW photographs at every ISO setting after which equalize the photograph brightnesses in submit processing to match noise ranges. The ensuing comparability supplies a characterization of the noise we will anticipate from every of these ISO settings in very darkish circumstances or extremely underexposed parts of a picture.

Most trendy digital camera sensors have a tendency to profit a bit of bit in very low mild through the use of reasonably boosted ISOs and that’s what we are likely to anticipate from this check. Finally, we need to discover the bottom ISO setting that also has adequately clear shadow particulars… that’s often one of the best ISO setting to make use of in very darkish capturing circumstances, particularly once we are shutter velocity restricted.

Check Particulars:

I took a visit to the Griffith Observatory in Los Angeles for this check. The Observatory is a superb check of low-light efficiency as a result of it provides fairly darkish capturing circumstances with the problem of the adjoining brightly lit Los Angeles basin.

Every telephone was arrange individually on the identical tripod to border roughly the identical shot. All of the telephones have been set to a tough publicity equal that makes an attempt to match 1/15th and f/1.7. Since every digital camera has a unique most aperture, the shutter time was accordingly adjusted for reciprocity.

For instance, the ZenFone 4 Pro’s telephoto lens has an f/2.6 aperture, virtually 2 stops slower than f/1.7 so I compensated with a shutter time of 1/4th of a second. As soon as arrange, the digital camera was held at one shutter time and the ISO was adjusted in full-stop increments throughout the ISO vary functionality of the digital camera from lowest to highest. All pictures have been recorded in RAW.

ISO-Invariance Example Test Frame

ISO-Invariance Instance Check Body

After capturing the check photographs, all of the exposures made have been adjusted to match brightness of the ISO 800 publicity in post-processing. Then we examine a 100% crop of an identical portion of the picture (highlighted within the check body above). The ensuing comparisons can be found under:

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro ISO Invariance Test (Standard Lens)

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro ISO-Invariance Check (Commonplace Lens Digital camera)

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro ISO Invariance Test (Tele Lens)

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro ISO-Invariance Check (Telephoto Lens Digital camera)

For the ASUS Zenfone 4, we have now two units of ISO-invariance checks: One for the usual lens digital camera and one for the telephoto lens digital camera. Every digital camera makes use of a special sensor so it’s essential that we shot with every to see if there are any variations.

Instantly, each of the the Zenfone 4 Pro cameras look like almost ISO-less or ISO-invariant. There’s barely any distinction between the totally different ISO settings when it comes to noise. From ISO 100 to ISO 3200, the quantities of noise look just about the identical for each cameras. There’s a small lack of spotlight element for ISOs of 1600-3200, indicating that we’re dropping slightly dynamic vary at these settings. The bottom ISOs, 25 and 50, are a bit bit noisier within the shadows and there’s a slight shade shift at these lowest settings.

Upon the closest scrutiny, it seems like there’s slightly little bit of profit to the shadows by capturing at ISOs of 400 and better. For the perfect leads to very low-light images, use the ASUS Zenfone 4 Pro at ISOs of 400 and better. However general, a lot of the ISO settings look comparable sufficient that we don’t actually need to fret about it an excessive amount of.


HTC U11 ISO-Invariance Check

The HTC U11 has probably the most restricted ISO vary of our 4 telephones within the comparability and no secondary digital camera so there are solely 4 check frames wanted to check for ISO-invariance. The very first thing that we discover is that the ISO 100 setting has a outstanding shade shift within the shadows and better ranges of noise versus the opposite settings. ISO 200 is far cleaner and ISO 400 even cleaner nonetheless. ISO 800 seems virtually similar to ISO 400.

General, ISO 200 to ISO 800 are very comparable. Shadow particulars are comparatively clear throughout these settings and general colour saturation appears to be larger out of the digital camera than the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. For one of the best outcomes with the U11 in low-light situations, the story could be very a lot the identical because the ZenFone 4 Pro: Keep at or above ISO 400 for one of the best shadows. Keep away from ISO 100 when you’re in very darkish circumstances since shadow particulars usually are not nicely retained and darkish areas are likely to have an unsightly magenta colour shift. It’s unusual that ISO 100 has this challenge on the U11 whereas the ZenFone 4 Pro, which shares the identical sensor on the first digital camera, doesn’t.

LG V30

LG V320 ISO Invariance Test (Standard Lens Camera)

LG V30 ISO-Invariance Check (Commonplace Lens Digital camera)

LG V320 ISO Invariance Test (Wide Angle Lens Camera)

LG V30 ISO-Invariance Check (Extensive Angle Lens Digital camera)

The LG V30 shares a few of the similar limitations at ISO 100 and decrease that we noticed with the HTC U11: shadow particulars are shifted to magenta colour and noise is extra of an issue at these low ISOs. The ugly shadows tends to be extra of a problem on the first digital camera, however nonetheless exhibits a bit with the V30’s broad angle digital camera, too. From ISO 400 and better, the outcomes look almost equivalent, a well-known story to the opposite telephones on this comparability.

The V30 can also be extra saturated, just like the U11, which makes me assume that the ASUS Zenfone 4 Pro is definitely the exception with its extra subued and desaturated pictures. General, the check signifies that photographers ought to keep at ISO 400 and better for one of the best leads to low-light with the LG V30. At these larger ISOs, particulars are comparatively clear and noise ranges aren’t too dangerous. Most of all, restoration of the darkest areas of the photograph can be simpler at these barely elevated ISO settings. Simply understand that just a little little bit of highlights will begin to be misplaced on the highest of ISOs.

General conduct of the V30’s sensor is comparatively ISO invariant from 400 to 3200 which appears to be a development…

Samsung Galaxy S8

Samsung Galaxy S8 ISO Invariance Test

Samsung Galaxy S8 ISO-Invariance Check

The Samsung Galaxy S8 appears to be as ISO-invariant because the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro, albeit with a narrower complete ISO vary (solely ISO 50 to ISO 800). Upon preliminary inspection, there’s little distinction between ISO 50 and ISO 800 when it comes to noise. However with a better look, it seems that ISO 200 and better appear to be the cleanest. ISO 100 has somewhat bit extra shadow noise. Aside from that, the Samsung S8 is properly ISO-invariant. If you wish to make sure the cleanest shadows for restoration in post-processing, ISO 200 and better is advisable on the Samsung S8.

It’s notable that the RAW information out of the S8 are only a tad extra desaturated than these from the U11 and V30 however nonetheless extra vibrant than the somewhat flat pictures type the ASUS Zenfone 4.

ISO Invariance Check Conclusions

General, I’m fairly proud of how the Samsung Galaxy S8 and the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro carried out throughout their ISO ranges. Each these telephones’s low-light pictures are tremendous clear throughout the ISO vary. A particular commendation ought to exit to the ZenFone 4 Pro because it’s capable of maintain consistency throughout the widest ISO vary of all of the telephones.

The decrease ISO settings on the V30 and U11 endure from elevated chroma noise and a magenta shift. That stated, the outcomes from the LG V30 and the U11 aren’t dangerous… they’re simply totally different and we should always use these telephones’ cameras accordingly. If capturing in very darkish circumstances, photographers with the V30 and U11 ought to be cautious of utilizing the bottom ISOs as these settings are likely to make shadow restoration harder.

Unusually, plainly the improved low ISO efficiency of the ZenFone 4 Pro have to be as a result of some sort of downstream processing that ASUS is implementing as a result of the it shares the identical sensor because the U11. We might have anticipated each the U11 and the ZenFone 4 Pro to behave the identical because the sensors are the identical however that doesn’t appear to be the case.

For all of the telephones, low-light capturing often requires a small bump in ISO, often to about ISO 400 or larger for one of the best retention of shadow particulars and the least shadow noise.

Straight ISO 800 Noise Comparability:

Instantly evaluating noise ranges between every telephone digital camera is somewhat bit tough due to some elements: sensor sizes and lens speeds are totally different between all these telephones. That stated, it’s nonetheless a solution to characterize which telephone is making one of the best use of its hardware for any given normal publicity settings. Right here’s a comparability of ISO 800 photographs between every digital camera. I’ve determined to make use of ISO 800 has the benchmark because it’s top-of-the-line (cleanest) settings on all of the telephones with regards to capturing low-light.

ISO 800 Comparability

I need to emphasize that this comparability ought to be taken with a grain of salt. It’s a reasonably good option to characterize what to anticipate from every digital camera nevertheless it’s not likely a great check of precise efficiency since every digital camera is so totally different (totally different sensors, sensor sizes, lenses, f/numbers) and equal exposures and different white stability settings have been used

Maintaining with tendencies, the ZenFone 4 Pro seems cleaner than any of the opposite telephones when it comes to general noise. There’s almost no shade noise which tells me that ASUS is probably going making use of some totally different downstream processing than the opposite producers. That’s good and dangerous information. Straight out of the digital camera, the pictures from the ZenFone 4 look cleaner. Noise is lowered in comparison with the competitors and shadow element appears to be higher. That stated, it additionally signifies that ASUS is processing out some colour info and it’s probably the trigger for RAW photographs that are likely to look somewhat flat and uninteresting.

The U11 truly appears identical to a extra saturated model of the ZenFone 4 Pro’s main digital camera… they share the identical Sony IMX362 sensor so similarities are just about anticipated. I think about that if ASUS was not baking their shade noise discount into their RAWs, they’d look lots like the pictures from the U11. Aside from a little bit of chroma noise, the U11 photographs are comparatively good. Grain is ok and shadow particulars are nonetheless sharp.

The LG V30 main digital camera appears to take a little bit of successful in noise efficiency regardless of its quick f/1.6 lens… that is doubtless resulting from the truth that the V30 main digital camera is utilizing a smaller 1/three.06″ sensor versus the 1/2.55″ in all the opposite telephones’ main cameras. There additionally appears to be some heavy noise discount processing baked in. Dare I say, it look surprisingly just like Sony’s star eater post-processing. The shadow particulars appear a bit extra muddied up by the processing and general superb particulars are extra smeared in look. High quality shiny pinpoint lights additionally look a bit mushy. It seems just like the f/1.6 lens on the LG V30 is just not as a lot of a bragging proper for low-light images as we initially thought.

Lastly, the S8 seems fairly just like the U11. Some colour noise is current however high-quality particulars are preserved and grain is comparatively high-quality. Making out shadow particulars isn’t fairly nearly as good because the U11 or ZenFone 4 Pro, however it’s higher than the LG V30.

Low Mild PerformanceWinner: ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro

As soon as once more, the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro leads the pack. It’s clear that the ZenFone 4 Pro out performs the competitors in low-light capturing. Its prolonged ISO vary is beneficial in any respect settings and exhibits comparable efficiency from ISO 25 all the best way as much as ISO 3200. Its RAW pictures do seem extra muted straight out of the digital camera however that’s one thing that may be simply adjusted for in submit processing.

Lens Efficiency: Sharpness and Aberration

Night time images is notoriously difficult for digital camera lenses. Vibrant pinpoints of sunshine are a number of the most telling indicators of lens aberrations. Given the extraordinarily small lens designs present in smartphone cameras, we don’t actually anticipate jaw-dropping efficiency from any of those cameras on the subject of sharpness or aberration efficiency. To check these cameras out, we shot some pictures of the Los Angeles basin from Griffith Observatory. The distant metropolis lights make for an ideal check of aberration efficiency.

Instance Aberration and Sharpness Check Body: ASUS ZenFone 4 Normal Lens Digital camera

Every telephone digital camera was used to shoot an identical photograph of the LA basin. There are some variations in composition between these check frames as a consequence of altering circumstances (crowds forcing me to maneuver and marine layer) however all of them have metropolis lights throughout the width of the body. 100% crops from every check body are proven under. Full decision pictures of the complete body can be found within the captions.

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Aberration Test: Standard Lens Camera

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Aberration and Sharpness Check: Normal Lens Digital camera. Full Decision.

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Aberration Test: Telephoto Lens Camera

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Aberration and Sharpness Check: Telephoto Lens Digital camera. Full Decision.

The ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro present good sharpness from each its normal and telephoto lens cameras when wanting on the middle of the body. The usual lens, nevertheless, exhibits some noticeable coma aberration and a bit of little bit of sharpness discount on the fringe of the body. The telephoto lens digital camera is surprisingly sharp on the fringe of the body with little or no aberration to talk of.


HTC U11 Aberration and Sharpness Check. Full Decision.

The HTC U11 seems to be even a tad higher than the usual digital camera on the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro within the middle of the body. The distant buildings of downtown Los Angeles and the adjoining valley areas are very sharp and finely detailed. The sting of the body takes a tangible hit in sharpness however the aberrations are rather less robust when in comparison with the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. General, I feel the U11 is fairly spectacular within the sharpness division.

LG V30

LG V30 Aberration and Sharpness Check: Commonplace Lens Digital camera. Full Decision.

LG V30 Aberration and Sharpness Check: Large Angle Lens Digital camera. Full Decision.

The LG V30 present some points with sharpness in lengthy publicity night time images. The pictures have low ranges of noise but in addition look a bit bit smeared, possible resulting from a baked in noise discount algorithm. The ensuing pictures have taken a tangible hit in sharpness when in comparison with the Zenfone 4 Pro and HTC U11.

An in depth take a look at pinpoint mild sources exhibits some that seem like donuts… a tell-tale indication that the V30 is implementing an identical noise discount algorithm because the Sony star eater challenge discovered on Sony Alpha cameras. Notice that these are samples constructed from RAW recorded information so there’s no strategy to disable the noise discount so far as I can discover.

Had the V30 not had the problems with this overzealous noise discount, I feel the middle pictures are comparatively aberration free. The sides of the usual lens digital camera are respectable with low ranges of aberration however the extensive angle lens has a couple of issues with coma or astigmatism aberration. It’s clear that LG is prioritizing noise over sharpness. The pictures look almost noise free when in comparison with the competitors however they’re additionally missing in superb element.

Samsung Galaxy S8

Samsung Galaxy S8 Aberration and Sharpness Test

Samsung Galaxy S8 Aberration and Sharpness Check. Full Decision.

The Samsung Galaxy S8 exhibits good sharpness within the middle of the body and equally good efficiency on the sides as nicely. Although sharpness seems to be to be higher than that of the LG V30, there are nonetheless some tell-tale indicators of some unusual noise discount being utilized: fantastic pinpoint mild sources appear to be donut shapes with darker facilities. It appears that evidently the S8 can also be making use of some sort of noise-reduction that compromises the looks of high quality pinpoint mild sources. It doesn’t look like almost a detrimental as on the LG V30, nevertheless it’s nonetheless current. There’s a small quantity of winged aberration current on the sides of the photograph however general sharpness is excellent. It’s general similar to the HTC U11 in sharpness and aberration efficiency.

Lens Efficiency Winner: HTC U11

If the HTC U11 will get one factor proper, it’s picture high quality. Whereas I can criticize the U11’s consumer interface and restricted ISO vary, picture high quality actually is actually spectacular. The sharpness of photographs comprised of its single main digital camera is superb and its aberration efficiency in low-light capturing is sort of good. Designing excessive efficiency lenses that at so small is not any easy engineering feat and HTC has excelled on the U11.

Finally, the low mild functionality of all these smartphones is spectacular and their inclusion of guide controls of their digital camera apps opens a world of prospects for night time images. I spent a number of nights in each Los Angeles and Chicago capturing pictures of those lovely cities with every of those smartphones.

Most of the lengthy publicity and light-trail pictures required using an adjunct clip-on thread and impartial density (ND) filter to realize lengthy shutter occasions. Under is a gallery of my capturing adventures with every of those telephones, together with a couple of extra notes on what it was like making the photographs and utilizing the telephone.

All of those pictures have been edited in Adobe Lightroom CC Basic utilizing my City Goals preset pack.

ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro Instance Pictures

Chicago Water Tower. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 10s, f/1.7, ISO 100

Chicago Water Tower. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 20s, f/1.7, ISO 25. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Capturing light-trail lengthy exposures of visitors with the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro is straightforward: the low ISO vary goes to ISO 25 which permits prolonged shutter occasions in comparatively vibrant situations, like this scene of Chicago’s previous Water Tower alongside the town’s Magnificent Mile. Right here, the decrease ISO vary allowed me to shoot extremely lengthy 20 second exposures the place a smartphone that was restricted to ISO 100 would solely be capable of use a 5 second publicity time.

Chicago Theater. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 2.5s, f/1.7, ISO 25

Chicago Theater. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 2.5s, f/1.7, ISO 25 Full Decision.

The low ISO functionality of the ZenFone 4 Pro additionally advantages the smartphone digital camera’s dynamic vary. Whereas capturing the very vibrant indicators of the Chicago Theater, I used to be capable of underexpose the scene to protect the element within the highlights of the picture after which carry the brightness of the shadows in submit processing for a excessive dynamic vary look. There’s just a little little bit of noise nevertheless it’s spectacular given the acute dynamic vary of the only publicity.

Marina City Towers, Chicago. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 20s, f/1.7, ISO 25

Chicago River. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 20s, f/1.7, ISO 25. ND Filter. Full Decision.

The ZenFone 4 Pro seems like utilizing a touchscreen DSLR and the images that it produces appear to be they could possibly be made with a a lot bigger sensor digital camera. Whereas its RAW information do begin off wanting very flat and unsaturated straight out of the digital camera, they reply nicely to some adjustment in submit processing.

Marina City Towers, Chicago. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 20s, f/1.7, ISO 25

DuSable Bridge, Chicago. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 25. Full Decision.

Once I set out with the ZenFone 4 Pro, it was, to say the least, very chilly, dropping to under 20°F with a robust wind for a lot of my capturing time. I really feel like this picture of the DuSable Bridge and the partially frozen Chicago River seize just a bit little bit of the chilly feeling I skilled that night time. Once I take a look at this picture, I really feel it’s typically onerous to consider that it was made with a smartphone.

Marina City Towers, Chicago. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 20s, f/1.7, ISO 25

Marina Metropolis Towers, Chicago. ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. 20s, f/1.7, ISO 25. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Strolling by way of the downtown Chicago space referred to as for nearly unique use of the usual extensive angle digital camera on the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro. I feel the 25mm focal size is snug for 90% of capturing with the ZenFone 4 Pro and I discovered myself not often wanting to make use of the telephoto digital camera.

Downtown Los Angeles. Asus ZenFone 4 Pro Telephoto. 4s, f/2.6, ISO 25. Full Decision.

That stated, the telephoto digital camera on the ZenFone 4 Pro is a type of issues that you simply don’t understand you’re keen on till you want it. When capturing in Los Angeles on the Griffith Observatory, the prolonged 50mm focal size was rather more applicable for capturing the distant skyline of downtown LA. Whereas the telephoto lens is just not as quick as the first digital camera, it’s nonetheless very able to low-light capturing with the right publicity settings and a tripod.

Griffith Observatory, Los Angeles. Asus ZenFone 4 Pro Telephoto. 20s, f/2.6, ISO 25. Full Decision.

General, I didn’t know what to anticipate from the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro once I began this comparability assessment. Taiwanese ASUS is extra well-known for his or her reasonably priced laptop computer computer systems than their smartphones and is never seen as a serious competitor to the large Korean names like Samsung and LG. I truthfully anticipated the ASUS to path behind on this comparability simply on account of its obscurity within the realm of the smartphone world. On the finish of all of it, I used to be blown away and left very impressed by the ZenFone 4 Pro and the pictures that it made.

HTC U11 Instance Pictures

Belden Stratford, Chicago. HTC U11. 32s, f/1.7, ISO 100

Belden Stratford, Chicago. HTC U11. 32s, f/1.7, ISO 100, ND Filter. Full Decision.

My early outings with the HTC U11 have been, to say the least, a bit irritating, principally due to the best way stay view publicity simulation works (or, slightly doesn’t work) and the truth that there isn’t any publicity meter readout. Even capturing an extended publicity of the nicely lit Belden Stratford constructing alongside Chicago’s Lincoln Park was a recreation of trial and error. It took me a number of tries to seek out the best mixtures of settings after ready for every publicity to finish.

Lakeview, Chicago. HTC U11. 1s, f/1.7, ISO 100. Full Decision.

After a little bit of apply with the U11 in any given situation, it’s not too troublesome to enhance at making guide exposures, it simply takes a while to attempt one publicity, evaluate the outcomes and modify accordingly. Regardless of a few of the problem to nail publicity on the primary attempt, I need to say that I used to be continuously impressed with the standard of the pictures made by the HTC U11.

Lincoln Park, Chicago. HTC U11. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 100

Lincoln Park, Chicago. HTC U11. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 100. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Particulars are typically very sharp and dynamic vary of the outcomes RAW information is usually excellent. I want desperately that HTC included a 4 second publicity cease on the shutter time adjustment slider. It’s usually very troublesome to be pressured to modify between as giant a variety as 2 and eight seconds, particularly once we additionally can’t choose partial cease ISO settings. It’s not unattainable to get an honest lengthy publicity, however it’s such a wierd factor for HTC to go away out.

Michigan Avenue, Chicago. HTC U11. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 100. Full Decision.

Little question, the hardware of the HTC U11 is succesful, however the smartphone is crippled by sub-par software program. It’s a disgrace as a result of I actually benefit from the photographs that the U11 makes as soon as the appropriate publicity is discovered.

South Pond, Lincoln Park, Chicago. HTC U11. 2s, f/1.7, ISO 100

South Pond, Lincoln Park, Chicago. HTC U11. 2s, f/1.7, ISO 100. Full Decision.

Taking an in depth take a look at night time cityscapes made on the U11 is a superb instance of how good the lens of its digital camera actually is the picture is sharp from edge to edge and pinpoint mild sources are rendered as such with very low quantities of aberration.

Los Angeles from Griffith Observatory. HTC U11. 1s, f/1.7, ISO 100

Los Angeles from Griffith Observatory. HTC U11. 1s, f/1.7, ISO 100. Full Decision.

One thing undesirable that I observed on sure photographs with the U11 was an uneven coloured vignette. On this picture of the Los Angeles basin from Griffith Observatory, you possibly can see that that may be a greenish round halo seen within the periphery of the sky. I consider that this is because of a software program vignetting compensation that HTC is making use of to the U11 RAW information. It’s not seen in all pictures however it may be detrimental in darkish conditions with clean gradients like this portrait of Los Angeles.

Griffith Observatory, Los Angeles. HTC U11. 2s, f/1.7, ISO 100

Griffith Observatory, Los Angeles. HTC U11. 2s, f/1.7, ISO 100. Full Decision.

The HTC U11 is characterised by wonderful hardware crippled by horrible software program. It’s absolutely able to performing nicely when it comes to picture high quality however getting there’s a ache on account of its poor consumer interface and restricted options. HTC is clearly nice at making succesful (even spectacular) hardware however I’d like to see HTC take a extra critical stance on their digital camera software program design sooner or later. In the meanwhile, it’s not excellent.

LG V30 Instance Pictures

St. Adalbert Church, Chicago. LG V30 Wide Angle. 8s, f/1.9, ISO 50

St. Adalbert Church, Chicago. LG V30 Broad Angle. 8s, f/1.9, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Ah sure, the LG V30. Capturing with this telephone was arguably probably the most enjoyable of the bunch and that’s for one cause alone: the extremely large angle digital camera. It’s definitely not the sharpest lens however the ensuing pictures greater than make up for some unsharp corners of their vast sweeping views. In a cityscape setting, the extremely large subject of view is an excellent software that opens new photographic prospects provided by no different smartphone producer.

Hancock Tower, Chicago. LG V30. 15s, f/1.9, ISO 50

Hancock Tower, Chicago. LG V30. 15s, f/1.6, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Whereas it’s protected to say that the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro has a small leg up when it comes to consumer expertise, the LG V30 comes very shut. Capturing photographs at night time tends to be very nice and the ensuing pictures are typically equally nice.

One factor that I did discover with the LG V30 particularly was it’s elevated proneness to flare round vibrant highlights when utilizing an ND filter. Whereas some flare is to be anticipated when utilizing a filter, for some purpose, the V30 confirmed stronger flares in comparison with the opposite telephones, even when utilizing the identical actual filter. I feel it may need one thing to do with the extremely reflective silver again of the telephone.

Chicago Water Tower. LG V30. 8s, f/1.9, ISO 50

Chicago Water Tower. LG V30 Broad Angle. 8s, f/1.9, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Simply to re-iterate simply how large the sector of view it on the V30: within the photograph above, the view is so extensive my impartial density filter ring exhibits up within the corners of the picture. There’s a few of that filter flare I’m speaking about however I don’t assume it’s overly detrimental to the picture.

Parking Lot on Elm St., Chicago. LG V30. 8s, f/1.6, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Whereas the extremely large angle lens is a ton of enjoyable, I’d say that it occupied about 50% of my capturing time with the LG v30. The first commonplace large angle digital camera is simply as helpful in most capturing conditions.

Hancock Tower, Chicago. LG V30. 15s, f/1.6, ISO 50

Hancock Tower, Chicago. LG V30. 15s, f/1.6, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

Lengthy publicity photographs from the LG V30 pictures look very clear out of digital camera however scrutinizing high-quality particulars exhibits that lengthy publicity photographs are a bit bit much less sharp than the competitors. It’s effective for what most individuals will use for his or her cellular pictures however if you need the best and sharpest particulars out of your cellular digital camera, the LG V30 falls a bit brief.

Los Angeles Basin from Griffith Observatory. LG V30 Large Angle. 8s, f/1.9, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

I actually loved having the choice of utilizing the extremely large subject of view. This picture of Los Angeles above actually captured the sensation of how giant with view from Griffith observatory was. It’s not the sharpest of pictures nevertheless it’s a shot that not one of the different smartphones on this comparability might have made.

Griffith Observatory. LG V30 Vast Angle. 30s, f/1.9, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

General, the LG V30 will get a number of issues proper in its digital camera expertise. I completely love the extremely vast angle digital camera and the consumer interface expertise on the guide publicity digital camera is excellent. I want wonderful element when utilizing lengthy publicity was higher. It’s clear that LG is cooking their V30 RAW information with some over zealous noise discount and that compromises sharpness and nice element rendering.

If the best of decision isn’t tremendous necessary, there’s just about no different digital camera producer providing an equal expertise as what’s discovered with the V30’s extremely large angle lens. It’s undoubtedly probably the most enjoyable to make use of of the telephones on this comparability.

Samsung Galaxy S8 Instance Pictures

North Pond, Lincoln Park, Chicago. Elm and State, Chicago. LG V30. 8s, f/1.6, ISO 50

North Pond, Lincoln Park, Chicago. Samsung Galaxy S8. 10s, f/1.7, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

The Samsung Galaxy S8 was usually good to make use of in low-light capturing conditions. I did discover some unusual coloured vignetting, just like what we noticed on the HTC U11 in sure conditions. Probably an indication that Samsung is making use of a software program lens vignetting correction to their RAW photographs. I’d want if these corrections have been disregarded of RAW information and as an alternative restricted to JPEGs.

Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum

Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum. Samsung Galaxy S8. 10s, f/1.7, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

I felt that the Samsung’s 10 second lengthy publicity restrict was not too huge of a problem for night time cityscapes however it does barely restrict the artistic potential of the S8’s digital camera not having a 30s publicity functionality. For many photographers, it shouldn’t be an excessive amount of of a deal breaker.

Roslyn Place, Chicago. Samsung Galaxy S8. 10s, f/1.7, ISO 50

Roslyn Place, Chicago. Samsung Galaxy S8. 10s, f/1.7, ISO 50. ND Filter. Full Decision.

The Samsung S8 is arguably the preferred and bestselling of the 4 smartphones on this comparability and it’s refreshing that Samsung has put a lot guide photographic energy into their flagship telephone.

Downtown Los Angeles from Griffith Observatory. Samsung Galaxy S8. 1s, f/1.7, ISO 50. Full Decision.

Shut scrutiny of the pinpoint mild sources within the above picture exhibits that there’s some unusual processing being utilized: the best pinpoints seem to have darkish facilities, as if Samsung is making use of the identical sort processing as on the LG V30. It’s not as detrimental to sharpness however as soon as once more, I want producers didn’t apply such robust processing to RAW picture information.

Griffith Observatory. Samsung Galaxy S8. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 50

Griffith Observatory. Samsung Galaxy S8. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 50. Full Decision.

The unusual vignetting gradient seen underneath some conditions on the S8 might be seen in on this portrait of Griffith Observatory.

Lincoln Park and Downtown Chicago. Griffith Observatory. Samsung Galaxy S8. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 50

Lincoln Park and Downtown Chicago. Griffith Observatory. Samsung Galaxy S8. 8s, f/1.7, ISO 50. Full Decision.

I did discover the occasional state of affairs when the S8 wouldn’t appear to nail focus completely, regardless of being set manually to infinity. It looks like there’s some variability within the focus mechanism on the S8.

Cloud Gate, The Bean, Chicago. Samsung Galaxy S8. 1s, f/1.7, ISO 50. Full Decision.

General, the Samsung Galaxy S8 will get plenty of issues proper. Its consumer interface is intuitive to make use of and I just like the accuracy of its publicity meter, even in low-light publicity conditions. I’d be very glad to have the Galaxy S8 in my pocket.

If there’s something that this comparability has made evident, it’s that smartphone cameras a really succesful low-light shooters. All 4 of those cameras have standout traits when capturing low-light exposures: the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro’s low-light efficiency and consumer expertise, the HTC U11’s lens sharpness, the LG V30’s extremely vast angle lens, and the Samsung S8’s general stability of picture high quality and consumer expertise.

The ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro was the large shock. Its design is a bit of “older” in look than than bezel-less S8 or V30, however beneath its normal wanting physique is a really highly effective digital camera. It excelled at low-light capturing throughout the board. It’s ensuing pictures impressed me most of any of those smartphone cameras. Most of all, The ZenFone 4 Pro provided one of the best consumer expertise I’ve had from a smartphone digital camera. If there’s one telephone I’d select amongst these 4, particularly for capturing pictures, the ASUS ZenFone 4 Pro is one of the best of the bunch.

Hopefully we’ll see smartphone producers additional enhance the photographic capabilities of the telephones by way of higher software program. We all know that the hardware will enhance over time and is already very succesful. It’s within the software program the place probably the most enhancements have to be made by most producers.

The ZenFone 4 Pro really felt prefer it has a totally properly rounded consumer interface expertise and it additionally had additional perks like the most important ISO vary and a real publicity simulation stay view feed when capturing in low-light circumstances. The Samsung S8 and LG V30 got here very shut however didn’t fairly match in consumer expertise or picture high quality, of which primarily got here right down to picture processing. The HTC U11 excelled in picture sharpness however fell flat when it got here to software program options and consumer interface design. Virtually all the damaging factors that may be made about any of those smartphones comes right down to software program.

I’m very excited the the prospect of capturing photographs that meet or exceed the picture high quality obtainable from a DSLR, all on a smartphone. We’re not fairly there but however I feel we’re getting very shut. I’ll all the time love utilizing my “real” full-sized digital camera however typically the most effective digital camera you’ve got is the one in your pocket.

All of the gear used for this comparability evaluation was loaned by B&H Photograph, with out which this evaluation wouldn’t have been attainable. Thanks a lot to the B&H staff for making this evaluate attainable. They’ve one of the best number of unlocked smartphones of any on-line retailer. Take a look at the listing of drugs that we used to make this assessment attainable:

We’re a participant within the B&H Affiliate Program which additionally permits us to earn charges by linking to

Study Astrophotography

Astrophotography 101 is totally free for everybody. All the classes can be found on the Lonely Speck Astrophotography 101 web page so that you can entry at any time. Enter your e-mail and each time we submit a brand new lesson you’ll obtain it in your inbox. We gained’t spam you and your e-mail will keep safe. Moreover, updates shall be despatched out solely periodically, often lower than as soon as per week.

Assist us assist you to!

Lonely Speck is my full-time job. It’s been a tremendous expertise for us to see a group develop round studying astrophotography and we’re so joyful to be a small a part of it. I’ve discovered that tremendous issues occur whenever you ask for assist so keep in mind that we’re all the time right here for you. When you’ve got any questions on images or simply need to share a narrative, contact us! In the event you discover the articles right here useful, contemplate serving to us out with a donation.


Thanks a lot for being part of our astrophotography journey.